H&HM Samurai (late) v Korean

Post your Battle Reports here
Post Reply
User avatar
Paul K
Posts: 292
Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2013 10:34 am
Contact:

H&HM Samurai (late) v Korean

Post by Paul K » Thu Nov 21, 2019 5:13 pm

The last time these two armies were pitted against each other the result was a very decisive Korean victory. In this long-awaited re-match, the army compositions for both were upgraded to give the Koreans more of their excellent ‘B’ class, bow armed, light and heavy cavalry. The Samurai army, in order to achieve a point match with the Koreans head more foot and mounted Samurai units and a few more ashigaru handgunners.
IMG_3833.JPG
The Samurai army advances in column towards the central woodland
In this 6 player game the three a side teams were decided by di roll – highest three v lowest three using a D12. Choice of table edge, first deployment and first move were decided in the same way.
IMG_3836.JPG
The Korean cavalry deployed in the open ground with the heavy cavalry to the extreme right of their line
IMG_3834.JPG
The Samurai infantry deploy in the woodland and on the reverse slope of the hills and escarpments.
Andre was borrowed from another gaming table to layout the terrain. This task had to be allocated to someone other than the players who had no prior knowledge of the opposing armies – these were still hidden away in the box! An open battlefield would favour the Koreans and one more cluttered and broken with hills and forests would suite the more infantry-based Samurai army. Andre, virtually emptied the terrain box of trees, hills and roads! This was going to be a Korean challenge!
IMG_3835.JPG
The Korean commanders contemplate how best to deal with the terrain.
IMG_3837.JPG
The Korean heavy cavalry advance along and beside the road.
The Koreans (Callum, Steve and Dave), won the Di roll for first move, but with a wall of trees stretching across half the battlefield between the 2 armies there wasn’t going to be any early contact. The Samurai ( Tony, Chris and I), had time to organise our units into a slow advance to best take advantage of the terrain. There were two further tactical moves by both sides before the shooters of both sides started to ‘tickle’ each other. The protection offered by the forests kept the Korean light cavalry from shooting away their weaker ashigaru opponents. Instead they formed a shooting line ready to blitz any Samurai units that dared to advance out of the forest hexes.
IMG_3842.JPG
The Korean cavalry engage the mounted Samurai.
IMG_3844.JPG
The Koreans hold the open ground while the Samurai try and work out the best way to attack.
On the other wing, Steve moved the massed units of Korean Heavy cavalry along the line of the road towards my waiting foot Samurai and ashigaru. This would not be a fair contest so I pulled back into the protection of a small area of woodland adjacent to the road.
IMG_3845.JPG
Korean spearmen, hand gunners and light cavalry, more than a match for the Samurai infantry.
In the centre of the field the Korean infantry advanced to within bow range of the ashigaru handgunners and a fire fight developed. The Samurai infantry advanced slowly towards the centre of the table through the extensive woodland, and as they finally broke cover, were out-shot by the Korean light cavalry which had come across and recoiled them disrupted back into woodland hexes.
IMG_3850.JPG
With the Korean heavy cavalry defeated the mounted Samurai advance along the road to confront the Korean light cavalry that has come across from the other wing.
The Koreans were masters of the open ground and the Samurai the forests! To try and break this impasse, Steve took the initiative and pressed home his Korean heavy cavalry attack on my left wing. Thankfully, Tony had sent three units of mounted Samurai across to assist my infantry, and as Steve’s cavalry demolished 2 units of ashigaru and sent a unit of foot Samurai fleeing into woodland, these new arrivals saved the day!
IMG_3852.JPG
The last Korean cavalry unit and it's general is surrounded by units of mounted Samurai.
With the Korean heavy cavalry units now committed to the battle on the left wing, Chris was able to advance his ashigaru infantry to engage the Korean infantry in the centre. Callum, in response moved his Korean light cavalry across from their left wing to the centre. By now most of the Samurai cavalry had now come across to support the Samurai left in the epic struggle with the Korean heavy cavalry. The resulting hand-to-hand combats saw heavy losses in units for both sides and when a Samurai general was lost along with his unit of mounted Samurai, Steve’s Koreans gained the upper- hand. However, this situation was soon reversed as in the next round of hand-to-hand combats Steve’s di rolls were frankly awful! This gained valuable time for the rest of the Samurai cavalry units to ‘pile in’ and as a result the bulk of Korean heavy cavalry was lost along with 2 generals.
IMG_3851.JPG
The Koreans conduct a fighting retreat.
Although the game had swung firmly in favour of the Samurai, the Korean infantry and light cavalry in the centre were still more than capable of holding their open ground and continued to out-shoot their opponents. They conducted a slow but steady, well organised fighting retreat towards their table edge, the Korean light cavalry quite capable of dealing with any attempt by the mounted Samurai to bring the retreating Koreans back into hand-to-hand combat by evading and shooting. A significant Samurai points win yes, but they failed to inflict a route on the Koreans.


Game analysis
The terrain layout with a significant number of hills and areas of forest was always going to present a challenge to the Korean bow armed cavalry. Once the Korean heavy cavalry had been committed against the Samurai left wing; the more open area of the table, and they were, after an epic struggle defeated, the Samurai win was guaranteed. Such was the terrain that the more numerous ashigaru infantry could always, with the assistance of the woodland hexes, hold and defeat the Korean cavalry. Credit must be given to the Korean commanders who played well when faced with very challenging terrain. Also, Steve’s poor di rolling also didn’t help his Korean heavy cavalry, especially when just a little luck was needed at a key point in the game!
Kind regards
Paul

Image
http://www.kallistra.co.uk

Post Reply